Irrigation Efficiency: Water use efficiency and various types of efficiencies

In irrigation engineering, Irrigation Efficiency is the ratio of the volume of water used to the volume of water delivered. High efficiency indicates a well-designed system with minimal losses during transport or application.

The following are the three most critical efficiency metrics used to evaluate a project:

A. Water Conveyance Efficiency ( $\eta_c$ )

This measures how much water is lost while traveling from the source (reservoir or river) to the farmer's field. Losses usually occur due to seepage, evaporation, and leakage in the canal network.

\eta_c = \left( \frac{W_f}{W_r} \right) \times 100

In irrigation engineering, Water Conveyance Efficiency ( $\eta_c$ $\eta_c$ ) is the measure of how much water is lost while it travels from the source (reservoir, river, or dam) to the farmer's field.

It is a critical metric for civil engineers when designing canal networks, as it identifies the losses occurring in the distribution system before the water even reaches the crops.

Mathematical Formula

The efficiency is expressed as the ratio of the water delivered to the field to the water diverted from the source:

\eta_c = \frac{W_f}{W_r} \times 100

Where:

Wf = Water delivered to the field (at the outlet).
Wr = Water diverted from the reservoir or headworks.

Major Causes of Conveyance Loss

In unlined canals, conveyance efficiency can be as low as 40% to 50%. The primary reasons for these losses are:

Seepage: Water soaking into the bed and banks of the canal. This is the biggest factor in earthen (unlined) canals.
Evaporation: Water turning into vapor from the surface of the canal, especially in hot, arid regions.
Transpiration: Water consumed by weeds and vegetation growing along the canal banks.
Leakage: Water escaping through cracks in lining, joints, or poorly maintained canal structures (gates, sluices).

How to Improve Conveyance Efficiency

To maximize the water reaching the fields, engineers implement several strategies:

Canal Lining: Covering the bed and sides with concrete, bricks, or boulders to prevent seepage. This is the most effective method.
Piped Distribution: Replacing open canals with underground pipes to eliminate both evaporation and seepage.
Weed Control: Regularly clearing vegetation from the canal banks to reduce transpiration losses.
Proper Maintenance: Fixing cracks in the lining and ensuring gates are watertight.

Comparison: Lined vs. Unlined Canals

Feature	Unlined Canal (Earthen)	Lined Canal (Concrete)
Conveyance Efficiency	Low ( $~45\%$ )	High ( $~80\% - 90\%$ )
Seepage Loss	Very High	Negligible
Maintenance Cost	High (silt/weeds)	Low
Initial Construction Cost	Low	High

B. Water Application Efficiency ( $\eta_a$ )

Once the water reaches the field, not all of it stays in the root zone. This efficiency accounts for losses due to surface runoff (water flowing out of the field) and deep percolation (water sinking below the roots).

Water Application Efficiency (ŋ $\eta_a$ ) focuses on how much of the water delivered to the field is actually stored in the root zone for the crops to use. While conveyance efficiency deals with the canal, application efficiency deals with the farmer's field.

It is the most important metric for determining if a specific irrigation method (like drip or sprinkler) is being used correctly.

Mathematical Formula

It is the ratio of the quantity of water stored in the root zone during irrigation to the quantity of water delivered to the field:

\eta_a = \left( \frac{W_s}{W_f} \right) \times 100

Common Water Losses in the Field

Even if you deliver 100 liters to a field, the plants won't get all of it. The "lost" water ( $W_f - W_s$ ) usually disappears in two ways:

Surface Runoff ( $R_f$ ): Water that flows over the ground surface and leaves the field without soaking in. This happens if the soil is too hard or the slope is too steep.
Deep Percolation ( $D_f$ ): Water that seeps down past the roots of the plants. Since the roots can't reach it, this water is wasted (though it may recharge groundwater).

Efficiency by Irrigation Method

Different methods have vastly different application efficiencies. This is a common topic for Civil Engineering exams.

Irrigation Method	Typical Efficiency (ηa)	Why?
Surface (Flooding)	40% – 60%	High runoff and deep percolation.
Sprinkler	60% – 80%	Better control, but some evaporation in the air.
Drip (Trickle)	90% – 95%	Water goes directly to roots; almost zero runoff.

Factors Affecting Application Efficiency
Soil Type: Sandy soils have high deep percolation, while clay soils may have high surface runoff.
Land Preparation: If the field isn't leveled, water will pool in one spot and stay dry in another.
Method of Irrigation: As shown above, pressurized systems (Drip/Sprinkler) are far more efficient than gravity systems.
Climate: High winds or extreme heat can cause water to evaporate before it even hits the soil (common in sprinkler systems).

NTS Pro-Tip for your Exam:

When calculating this in a numerical problem, remember that:

W_f = W_s + \text{Runoff} + \text{Deep Percolation}

If a question gives you the runoff and percolation amounts, subtract them from the delivered water to find $W_s$ first.

C. Water Storage Efficiency ( $\eta_s$ )

Plants need a specific amount of water to reach their full potential. This ratio compares how much water was actually stored in the root zone versus how much was needed to bring the soil to its field capacity.

\eta_s = \left( \frac{W_s}{W_n} \right) \times 100

Water Storage Efficiency ( $\eta_s$ ) is a measure of how effectively an irrigation session has met the water requirements of the soil. Unlike application efficiency (which focuses on how much water was wasted), storage efficiency focuses on how much of the needed water was actually delivered to the root zone.

Mathematical Formula

It is the ratio of the water stored in the root zone during irrigation to the water needed in the root zone prior to irrigation to bring it to its field capacity.

\eta_s = \left( \frac{W_s}{W_n} \right) \times 100

\eta_s = \left( \frac{W_s}{W_n} \right) \times 100

$W_s$ : Water stored in the root zone during irrigation.
$W_n$ : Water needed in the root zone prior to irrigation.

Why is Storage Efficiency Important?

If $\eta_s$ is low, it means the crop is "under-irrigated." This leads to:

Water Stress: The plants cannot get enough moisture, leading to stunted growth.
Salt Accumulation: In some soils, if you don't apply enough water to occasionally "flush" the soil, salts can build up and ruin the land.
Reduced Yield: Even if your application method is 100% efficient, if you only give the plant half of what it needs ( $\eta_s = 50\%$ ), the crop will fail.

The "Field Capacity" Connection

To calculate $W_n$ (the water needed), engineers look at the difference between the Field Capacity (the maximum water the soil can hold against gravity) and the Existing Moisture Content before the water was turned on.

Factors Affecting Storage Efficiency

Irrigation Duration: Simply not running the pumps or opening the gates long enough.
Soil Permeability: In very tight clay soils, water might run off before it has time to soak deep enough to reach the full W $W_n$ .
Depth of Root Zone: If the roots go 1 meter deep but you only wet the top 0.5 meters, your storage efficiency for that root zone is low.

D. Water Use Efficiency (WUE)

This is a broader term often used by agronomists to link engineering with crop production. It is the yield of the crop per unit of water used.

Water Use Efficiency is defined as the weight of the crop produced per unit of water consumed by the crop through evapotranspiration.

In simpler terms: How much grain or fruit did we get for every liter of water used?

Crop Water Use Efficiency: $\frac{\text{Yield of Crop}}{\text{Evapotranspiration of Crop}}$
Field Water Use Efficiency: $\frac{\text{Yield of Crop}}{\text{Total Water used in the Field}}$

It tells us how much "output" (crop yield) we get for every "input" (unit of water).

Types of Water Use Efficiency

There are two main ways civil engineers and agronomists calculate this:

A. Crop Water Use Efficiency ( $WUE_{crop}$ )

This focuses strictly on the water the plant actually "breathes out" and uses to grow.

WUE_{crop} = \frac{Y}{ET}

$Y$ : Yield of the marketable crop (kg or tonnes).
$ET$ : Evapotranspiration (the sum of evaporation from soil and transpiration from the plant).

B. Field Water Use Efficiency ( $WUE_{field}$ )

This is the more practical metric for a civil engineer. it includes all the water delivered to the field, including the water lost to runoff or deep percolation.

WUE_{field} = \frac{Y}{WR}

$Y$ : Yield of the marketable crop.
$WR$ : Total water requirement (water delivered to the field).

Why WUE is Critical for Engineering

As a civil engineer managing an irrigation project, improving WUE is your ultimate goal. You can improve it by:

Reducing Conveyance Losses: Lining canals so more water reaches the field.
Choosing the Right Method: Switching from surface flooding to Drip Irrigation significantly increases $WUE_{field}$ because $WR$ (water requirement) decreases while $Y$ (yield) stays the same or increases.
Mulching: Covering the soil to reduce the "Evaporation" part of $ET$ .
Proper Timing: Irrigating at night or early morning to minimize evaporation.

NTS Pro-Tips:

A high ŋa (Application Efficiency) is good for the environment, but a high WUE is what makes a farm successful.

For example, in a desert region, a farmer might have 95% application efficiency using a drip system, but if they grow a crop that requires too much water for that climate, the WUE will still be low.

NTS STUDY